AMA and Electric Motorcycles in AMA races


Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Well it looks like the AMA is not exactly ready to join Motorcycling Australia, FFM and others in letting electrics race everywhere.

They've been competing all over Europe national or local championships, plus 2 years of pro racing AX UK, SX tour, now competing in world championship (FIM Superenduro), it's apparently not enough.


Gotta say I haven't found the 2025 AMA rules yet.
 

UKLee

Well-known member
Likes
71
Location
UK
Sounds to me it is because the stark does not have the range which we know. It has less than half the 450 with a full tank range we were promised, hardly the AMA's fault.
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Sounds to me it is because the stark does not have the range which we know. It has less than half the 450 with a full tank range we were promised, hardly the AMA's fault.
Well they're actually backtracking, banning electrics from series they were racing last year which doesn't really make sense to me.

Motorcycling Australia made a point that "normal race distance, duration or times should not be altered to accommodate electric machines".
Agreed completely, it's up to the riders to decide if they want to compete, to assess if they can clear a loop or two or whatever. Or organizers could limit the participation of electrics to short courses if that's really an issue to them?

Varg riders have been racing GNCC 2h morning race at a few rounds, US Sprint Enduro series at most rounds as well, got some very decent overall results in both.

Seems a very odd reason to keep electric bikes out, especially saying that if they get their own class then it's all fine?
Hopefully if there's more than 3 e riders at GNCC, other organizers could see the benefit of adding a class. Why would they refuse entry fees?
 
Likes
19
Location
Waupaca, Wisconsin

The AMA gave the Stark a place to race and only a few people are showing up. I can't blame the AMA for not giving a crap about them. Motocross/Supercross is about 90% hardcore redneck and they don't want them. I wouldn't be surprised if Stark quits making MX bikes and focuses on woods bikes and people doing wheelies in the city. The best advancement they could make in the MX world is to get them running on diesel. Can you imagine how awesome it would be to roll coal with your dirt bike!!!11!
 

Theo

Well-known member
Likes
170
Location
Italy
Motocross/Supercross is about 90% hardcore redneck and they don't want them.
I partially agree; IMO:
yes, it's true that a lot of motocrossers, possibly most of them, don't want them.
No, they are not redneck, they just follow the trend of saying that EVs are pathetic and, when you just go with the flow, it doesn't matter how well you could potentially think, because you are not thinking.
Not everybody hate them, though and one positive thing is that it seems to me that there are more people who used to hate electrics but then change their minds and are glad to have done it than those who give electrics a try and decide to go back to gas.
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France

The AMA gave the Stark a place to race and only a few people are showing up. I can't blame the AMA for not giving a crap about them. Motocross/Supercross is about 90% hardcore redneck and they don't want them. I wouldn't be surprised if Stark quits making MX bikes and focuses on woods bikes and people doing wheelies in the city. The best advancement they could make in the MX world is to get them running on diesel. Can you imagine how awesome it would be to roll coal with your dirt bike!!!11!
That's an interesting vid, a peak into a possible future.

First, I think that's great that the AMA did that for Arenacross, both the electric class and the clash for cash (non-point scoring race mixing electrics with ICE). But they've communicated on this maybe 2 weeks before the start of the championship so you can't reasonably expect to have too many riders show up. Currently it's more like an initiation to electrics for riders from the main pro class. It's terrific to see Hicks winning both the ICE and electrics class and lapping at very similar pace on his Yamaha and on his Stark.

Another point that really gets lost in this kind of conversation is that obviously, electrics as a spectator sports would not appeal to a huge fraction of current fans (rightfully) addicted to noise and vibrations of ICE. I love electric bikes and even for me it's weird, because it's different, it's new.
But the more interesting question (to me at least) is: could getting rid of deafening noise broaden the appeal of the sport, could it bring more families, crossover with MTB crowd is obvious, what will younger generations (more and more learning to ride on electrics) think about it? They will never miss the smell of 2T because they have not really been exposed to it, would they miss the ear shattering 4T?

In the end what the kids make of it matters most than what us old farts think of it. They get to decide what the future of the sport will be, not us.
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Another win by Zaragoza against ICE, this time in Argentina, you can read his thoughts about pros and cons of racing electrics (as a rider, not a spectator 😉)

 

Johnny Depp

Well-known member
Likes
98
Location
Austin TX
Well they're actually backtracking, banning electrics from series they were racing last year which doesn't really make sense to me.

Motorcycling Australia made a point that "normal race distance, duration or times should not be altered to accommodate electric machines".
Agreed completely, it's up to the riders to decide if they want to compete, to assess if they can clear a loop or two or whatever. Or organizers could limit the participation of electrics to short courses if that's really an issue to them?

Varg riders have been racing GNCC 2h morning race at a few rounds, US Sprint Enduro series at most rounds as well, got some very decent overall results in both.

Seems a very odd reason to keep electric bikes out, especially saying that if they get their own class then it's all fine?
Hopefully if there's more than 3 e riders at GNCC, other organizers could see the benefit of adding a class. Why would they refuse entry fees?
The AMA is pretending that the lack of sound is unsafe and won’t allow the gas and E together, only separate with pre approval. They are merely using their insurance availability to dictate the desires of their OEM partners. It will change when Honda is done slow walking their E bike.
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Australia gets it

Varg is legal to race anything (MX, enduro) at any level (club, state, national).

Well, except Supercross. Now I hate to be a cynic but what could be the reason here?
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Great to hear from Hicks, starting at 57 min, about racing the Stark and Yamaha in AMA Arenacross. He'd be interested to race Arenacross UK (just did Dortmund on a Yamaha) and would rather race the Stark next year if they're allowed in the main class.

 

UKLee

Well-known member
Likes
71
Location
UK
Well they're actually backtracking, banning electrics from series they were racing last year which doesn't really make sense to me.

Motorcycling Australia made a point that "normal race distance, duration or times should not be altered to accommodate electric machines".
Agreed completely, it's up to the riders to decide if they want to compete, to assess if they can clear a loop or two or whatever. Or organizers could limit the participation of electrics to short courses if that's really an issue to them?

Varg riders have been racing GNCC 2h morning race at a few rounds, US Sprint Enduro series at most rounds as well, got some very decent overall results in both.

Seems a very odd reason to keep electric bikes out, especially saying that if they get their own class then it's all fine?
Hopefully if there's more than 3 e riders at GNCC, other organizers could see the benefit of adding a class. Why would they refuse entry fees?
"Well they're actually backtracking, banning electrics from series they were racing last year which doesn't really make sense to me."

My guess is they listened to the claims stark made on range but when they saw the range was about half and they were left with out of charge starks littering the track that needed to be recovered changed there mind.
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Karlsson got 4th overall (3rd Superpole then 2nd, 6th and 5th) in FIM Superenduro round 4.

Interesting bit on Enduro21:

"note the FIM have relaxed their restrictions on the Varg slightly with each round and they again took some weight off the bikes this weekend"

FIM can decide to change balancing rules at any time and it's not directly correlated to position, points, times or anything.

Turns out they're at version 3 of the "FIM equivalence of technologies - balance of performances".

V3 is minimum weight 117 kg (stock road legal bike is 120 kg) and no restriction on power anymore while restrictions on torque are still "TBA at a later stage".

2025_3_SuperEnduro Electric EOT-BOP_27.01.2025 | FIM
 

Beagle

Well-known member
Likes
319
Location
France
Keeping an eye on Michael Hicks laptimes in AMA Arenacross

Hicks counter, Reno edition

round 8
X (Stark) quali 28.887, M1 29.325, M2 29.543
AX (Yamaha) quali 29.122, M1 29.126, M2 29.180

round 9
X (Stark) quali 30.314, M1 30.613, M2 30.416
AX (Yamaha) quali 29.930, M1 30.465, M2 31.117
 
Top Bottom